READ NEXT

7 Books Like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder

If you loved A Good Girl's Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson, you probably want another mystery that lets you investigate alongside the main character.

Pip Fitz-Amobi's determination to reopen a closed murder case is what makes her story so compelling. She questions the accepted version of events, follows overlooked evidence, and gradually discovers that the people around her are keeping dangerous secrets.

The best books like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder offer more than a shocking crime. They feature memorable teenage investigators, convincing mysteries, complicated relationships, and clues that invite readers to form their own theories.

These seven YA mystery and thriller series offer different versions of that experience, from boarding-school cold cases to small-town tragedies and psychological investigations.

A Good Girl's Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson

A quick place to start

Quick Picks: What to Read After A Good Girl's Guide to Murder

Quick Picks: What to Read After A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
If you loved...Try this seriesWhy it fits
Cold cases and carefully planted cluesTruly DeviousA teenage detective investigates an old disappearance
Teenage girls challenging the police's theoryThe AgathasTwo unlikely partners investigate a suspicious death
True-crime obsession and amateur detective workThe AmateursTeenagers work together on an unsolved disappearance
School secrets and multiple suspectsOne of Us Is LyingA student's death exposes the secrets of his classmates
Hidden truths about an old local tragedyThe CheerleadersA girl questions the circumstances surrounding multiple deaths
Criminal psychology and disturbing investigationsNone Shall SleepTwo young investigators assist the FBI
Clever teenage investigators and teamworkThe NaturalsGifted teenagers investigate dangerous criminal cases

1. Truly Devious — Maureen Johnson

Best for: Cold cases, clever clues, and determined teenage detectives

Stevie Bell arrives at Ellingham Academy with one ambition: to solve a famous unsolved crime.

Decades earlier, the school's founder suffered a devastating family tragedy involving a kidnapping and a disappearance. The mystery has never been fully resolved, and Stevie believes that examining the original evidence may finally reveal what happened.

But the school's strange history soon becomes entangled with events in the present. As Stevie investigates, she must balance her obsession with the case against friendships, school life, and people whose motives are difficult to understand.

Why it's similar

Like Pip, Stevie is fascinated by an unresolved mystery and refuses to accept easy explanations. Both protagonists follow evidence, question witnesses, and notice connections that others overlook.

How it's different

Truly Devious uses a distinctive boarding-school setting and a mystery stretching across different time periods. Its investigation develops across a larger puzzle rather than beginning with Pip's contemporary school project.

2. The Agathas — Kathleen Glasgow and Liz Lawson

Best for: Amateur sleuths, suspicious deaths, and unlikely friendships

Alice Ogilvie has already experienced what it means to become the subject of local gossip. After disappearing for several days, she returns to Castle Cove unwilling to explain what happened.

Then Brooke Donovan, Alice's former best friend, disappears. When the case turns into a murder investigation, attention falls on someone Alice believes may have been wrongly accused.

Alice joins forces with Iris Adams, a classmate whose life is very different from her own. Inspired partly by Agatha Christie's detective stories, the two girls begin looking for answers that the adults around them may have missed.

Why it's similar

This is one of the strongest choices for readers who enjoyed Pip's determination to question an established police theory. Both stories involve teenage investigators, suspicious deaths, misleading appearances, and communities full of secrets.

How it's different

The Agathas relies on the partnership between Alice and Iris rather than one central investigator. It also brings more classic-detective-fiction inspiration and contrasting personalities into the mystery.

3. The Amateurs — Sara Shepard

Best for: True-crime enthusiasts and collaborative investigations

A group of teenagers who are fascinated by unsolved crimes come together to investigate a disappearance that continues to raise questions.

What begins as a shared interest in true crime develops into a real investigation. As the teenagers compare information, uncover connections, and follow leads, they discover that the people involved have reasons to hide what they know.

Their growing involvement also makes the mystery more dangerous than they initially expected.

Why it's similar

Pip's school project gradually becomes an investigation with serious consequences. The Amateurs offers a related progression, with young people moving from an interest in criminal cases to actively searching for answers themselves.

How it's different

Instead of focusing primarily on one determined detective, The Amateurs follows a group with different perspectives and personal motivations. Team dynamics are central to how the investigation develops.

4. One of Us Is Lying — Karen M. McManus

Best for: School mysteries, multiple suspects, and buried secrets

At Bayview High, a student's suspicious death during detention exposes the secrets and conflicting accounts of four classmates who suddenly find themselves under investigation.

When Simon, the student behind a notorious gossip app, dies under suspicious circumstances, the surviving teenagers become the focus of a murder investigation.

Each has private information they would rather keep hidden, and Simon had planned to expose their secrets. As the story unfolds through different perspectives, readers must decide which details are meaningful and which characters can be trusted.

Why it's similar

Both stories show how a crime can reveal the hidden tensions beneath an ordinary school community. Rumors, reputations, concealed relationships, and misleading assumptions are essential to each mystery.

How it's different

A Good Girl's Guide to Murder follows Pip actively investigating a crime. One of Us Is Lying places several central characters under suspicion, making their conflicting accounts part of the puzzle.

5. The Cheerleaders — Kara Thomas

Best for: Small-town secrets and investigations into past tragedies

Five years before the events of The Cheerleaders, the town of Sunnybrook lost five cheerleaders in a series of deaths.

Two died in a car accident. Two were murdered. The final girl, Monica's sister, died by suicide. The town has tried to move on, but Monica has never been able to put the tragedy completely behind her.

As strange clues begin appearing, Monica starts questioning whether the accepted explanations tell the whole story. Her search brings her closer to secrets that some people would prefer to remain buried.

Why it's similar

Both stories revisit disturbing events that a community believes are already understood. Like Pip, Monica finds reasons to question the official narrative and becomes increasingly involved in uncovering what happened.

How it's different

The Cheerleaders places greater emphasis on grief, family loss, and the emotional impact of an old tragedy. It is darker and more personal than a conventional amateur-detective investigation.

Start with: The Cheerleaders

Explore The Cheerleaders reading order →

6. None Shall Sleep — Ellie Marney

Best for: Darker crime investigations and psychological suspense

Emma Lewis survived a serial killer. Travis Bell hopes to become a U.S. Marshal and carries his own painful connection to violent crime.

The two teenagers are recruited to assist the FBI with interviews involving young convicted killers. Their work brings them into contact with dangerous personalities, disturbing crimes, and psychological manipulation.

As the investigation grows more complicated, both must confront the risks of getting close to people who understand how to exploit their fears.

Why it's similar

Like Pip, Emma and Travis are young people confronting serious crimes while struggling with the consequences of their involvement. Investigative reasoning, overlooked details, and threats to personal safety are important to both stories.

How it's different

None Shall Sleep is a darker, more psychologically intense thriller involving federal investigations and interviews with convicted killers. It is less focused on a realistic school-based amateur investigation.

7. The Naturals — Jennifer Lynn Barnes

Best for: Clever teenage investigators, criminal profiling, and team dynamics

Cassie Hobbes has an unusual talent for understanding people. Her ability draws the attention of a special FBI program that recruits gifted teenagers to help investigate cold cases.

At the program, Cassie meets other young people with exceptional investigative abilities. Their different talents make them a formidable team, but the crimes they examine become increasingly personal and dangerous.

The story combines criminal psychology, mysteries, friendships, and complicated relationships among teenagers working under extraordinary circumstances.

Why it's similar

Both series feature intelligent young protagonists whose investigative skills expose them to serious danger. Readers who admire Pip's observational abilities and determination may enjoy watching Cassie and her teammates analyze behavior and evidence.

How it's different

The Naturals is built around an FBI program and unusually gifted profilers. Its investigations involve a team and professional law-enforcement connections rather than a student independently reopening a local case.

Which Book Series Should You Read First?

If you want the closest match to Pip's approach to solving mysteries, start with Truly Devious or The Agathas.

Both feature teenage investigators who question accepted explanations and pursue evidence that others have overlooked. Truly Devious is especially appealing if you enjoy complicated clues and a mystery unfolding over several books, while The Agathas is a good choice if you prefer an investigative partnership.

If true-crime research is what captured your attention, try The Amateurs. Its young protagonists take their interest in unsolved cases beyond discussion and into an investigation of their own.

For readers who liked the secrets surrounding Pip's classmates and neighbors, One of Us Is Lying offers a different perspective: its main characters are themselves suspects in a murder.

Choose The Cheerleaders if you want an emotionally darker small-town mystery involving an old tragedy.

If the later books in Pip's series left you looking for more intense suspense, None Shall Sleep or The Naturals may be better choices. Both involve young people confronting dangerous criminals, but their investigative settings are very different.

The best choice depends on whether you most enjoyed Pip's detective work, the hidden secrets of her town, or the danger that followed her search for answers.

More Books by Holly Jackson

The Reappearance of Rachel Price

Bel Price has spent most of her life living with unanswered questions about her mother's disappearance. When a true-crime documentary revives public interest in the case, her mother suddenly returns with a story Bel finds difficult to believe.

This standalone mystery is a strong choice if you enjoyed Pip's determination to challenge a familiar explanation, especially when people close to her may not be telling the truth.

The Reappearance of Rachel Price — Penguin Random House →

Five Survive

A spring break road trip becomes a nightmare when six friends are trapped in an RV and realize someone outside is targeting them.

Unlike Pip's evidence-driven investigations, this standalone thriller emphasizes a ticking clock, escalating danger, and the secrets shared by people trapped together.

If you enjoyed the tension and uncertainty of the later A Good Girl's Guide to Murder books, Five Survive offers a faster, more contained thriller experience.

Five Survive — Penguin Random House →

Both books are standalone novels, not sequels to Pip's story.

Have You Read Every A Good Girl's Guide to Murder Book?

Before choosing another series, make sure you have not missed part of Pip's story.

The three main novels are A Good Girl's Guide to Murder, Good Girl, Bad Blood, and As Good as Dead. The supplementary prequel novella Kill Joy follows Pip during a murder-mystery party.

For first-time readers, the original novel remains the natural starting point. Visit our A Good Girl's Guide to Murder reading order for the full sequence and the novella's placement.

Frequently Asked Questions

What books are most like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder?

Truly Devious and The Agathas are especially good choices for readers who loved Pip's detective work and the search for overlooked evidence. The Amateurs also explores teenagers becoming involved in real unsolved cases.

What should I read after A Good Girl's Guide to Murder?

Choose Truly Devious for cold cases and intricate clues, One of Us Is Lying for high-school secrets and multiple suspects, or The Cheerleaders for a darker mystery involving an old town tragedy.

Are there other YA books with teenage detectives?

Yes. Truly Devious follows Stevie Bell, a student determined to solve a famous cold case. The Agathas features Alice and Iris working together on a murder investigation, while The Amateurs follows a group of teenage true-crime enthusiasts.

What Holly Jackson book should I read next?

The Reappearance of Rachel Price is a strong choice if you want another investigation involving hidden family truths and unreliable accounts. Five Survive is better if you prefer high-pressure suspense and a dangerous situation unfolding over a short period.

Explore More YA Mystery & Thriller Recommendations

Looking for another mystery to solve?

Browse our YA Mystery series for investigative stories, suspicious deaths, and hidden clues. You can also explore YA Thriller series for greater psychological tension and danger.

Read Next for additional recommendation guides, or browse the full YA Series Directory to compare book counts and reading orders.

Sources & Further Reading

For Truly Devious, The Amateurs, None Shall Sleep, and The Naturals, these links point to the official author or publisher source records used by the corresponding canonical series pages.